Brandon

C.

Programmer and Lifelong Student


Welcome to my blog

There was a point in time when I thought that filtering what I had to say was beneficial to my both personally and professionally. I have come to disagree with that initial assessment. Thus this blog contains a pretty raw view into my mind. You will find professional as well as personal posts here.

Abstract – Politics and Administration by Frank Goodnow

October 11, 2008admin10 Comments

PAF 602 (Fall 2008)

Abstract

Goodnow, F.J. (2003). Politics and Administration: A Study in Government. New Brunswick, NJ: Transaction Publishers.

Frank Goodnow’s classic work aims to express the separation of government authority beyond the traditional executive, legislative and judicial triad. Goodnow distinguishes and explains the dichotomy between elected legislators who enact the will of the state (politics) versus the officials and entities that are responsible for the execution of that will (administration). Goodnow outlines the separation of political and administrative authority in a comparative analysis between the United States and a number of European countries. His analysis and suggestions are predicated upon the efficient and legitimate formulation and exercise of the will of the people and the source of administrative legitimacy.

While, “the function of politics…consists in the expression of the will of the state” (p. 23), “the function of executing the will of the state has been called administration” (p. 72). The relation of politics to administration is one of separation and subordination. Goodnow argues that while politics can never be completely apart from administration, “…popular government requires that it is the executing authority (administration) which shall be subordinate to the expressing authority (politics)” (p. 24). The executing authority, according to Goodnow, should be one of centralized administration in contrast to decentralized or local administration and it should also not be overly controllable by the expressing authority for fear of impartial administration.

Political parties are central to Goodnow’s architecture of a popular government and efficient administration. His reasoning is that the role of powerful yet responsible political parties are a necessary means of expressing and executing the will of the state and that their power can be checked, as necessary, by “government organs” (p. 257). Having powerful political parties ensures that the will of the people is the will of the legislature, and thus through the aforementioned subordinate relationship, results in the effective administration of the people’s will.

Goodnow’s theory of a separation between politics and administration has pervaded the practice of public administration for years. The spoils system was abandoned long ago and the civil service system has placed the power of administration generally out of the hands of the legislature.

Critique

I found Goodnow’s work to be very informative and insightful. I think he makes a number of interesting correlations relating to the distribution of authority and the ideal of a separation between legislation and execution. I think that in an ideal world where the morals of individuals in administrative positions were always honorable, his suggestions might prove practical.

However, I cannot subscribe to the train of thought that legislation and administration can be entirely, or even mostly separated. All people, and hence any government organization comprised of them, are never without political and environmental influence. While it may be the job of administrators to act within the spirit of the encompassing legislation, I believe it impossible to impartially enact policy free of personal and external pressures.

As John Rohr pointed out in the introduction:

The discretionary nature of the powers exercised by administrators is unmistakably clear in the frequency with which vague words such as the following appear in statutes authorizing administrative action: adequate, advisable, appropriate, beneficial… (p. xx-xxi)

Words such as these leave incredible authority in the hands of administrative personnel and allows for subjective meanings influenced by anything from politics to the weather, to determine the supposed expression of the will of the people. I feel this to be one of the major flaws in Goodnow’s argument of a division between politics and central administration.

One aspect of Goodnow’s argument that I found particularly interesting was his comparison of administrators and the judiciary role. He reasons that judicial decisions are simply a means of executing the will of the state and that politics should not overly influence either the administration or the judiciary; thus he appears to view them as being rooted in the same foundation opposite politics. This thought has never occurred to me before but seems to make some sense. Unfortunately, the judiciary, by its nature, has authority over the legislature and thus would seem to be contradictory to Goodnow’s idea of administration as subordinate to politics.

This article has 10 comments
  1. Yusnia Sakti
    November 26, 2009

    Thanks to you. Finally I found some information of Politics and Admninistration by Frank J. Goodnow. Well, actually I don’t take any Administration subject but I have a translation job which belong to this, so this is really help me in finding the background of Politics and Administration.

  2. Leonardo
    December 28, 2010

    Verey good, L

  3. Chakradhar Dash
    October 29, 2011

    Thanks for this information about Goodnow’s contribution to public administration.

  4. Robert Burns
    April 18, 2012

    Administrators have no responsibility to voters … hence we find them doing any damn thing that seems to them a ‘good idea’, even though the people who pay their salaries may be diametrically opposed.

    GSA ‘partying’ is only the more recent expression of this opposition.

    • admin
      April 18, 2012

      I would argue that most politicians don’t have a whole lot of responsibility to voters either. The “Buffett Rule” is supported by 70% of the public yet Senate Republicans denied it. We continually see blatant disregard to public demands by politicians especially if those complaining are from a different political affiliation. I can’t even get my Republican representative to respond to me when I express opinions different than his. Yet when I write him to support something he is in favor of (rarely…bit it happens), I get a lovely mass-produced letter talking about America, values, and a bunch of other junk that has nothing to do with the root of the issue. If anything, administrators…otherwise known as bureaucrats, are more in touch with the general public than most politicians are. Do some abuse their positions, sure. But I am willing to bet that there are many more people in the private sector that behave in socially disadvantageous ways…the difference is that you simply dont know about it or you explain it way as it being their right to do whatever they want because they made their own money; no matter how dishonestly.

      Would you have all administrators be democratically elected? As someone who took a $20k pay cut from the private sector to work for the state in hopes that I could really make a difference (and I am btw), I find your stark generalizations and lack of insight unsettling yet representative of the anti-intellectualism running rampant in this country.

      Having said that…thank you for commenting on my blog. It is very much appreciated!

  5. geovannie
    July 16, 2012

    i need a basis and please gimme some.
    Is Goodnow’s notion of dichotomy of politics and administration applicable in the philippines? I need some idea of how could the Philippines uses this.. pls. i need it to make my reaction paper

    • admin
      July 16, 2012

      I believe that the dichotomy is applicable in most democracies with governments based on separation of powers. If the Philippines is like that, then I would imagine that it is applicable.

  6. zarah
    August 7, 2012

    I also agree with the dichotomy of politics and administration. But can you, can you comment on others idea that union of both is for the better interest of effective management and governance.

  7. Mahmood Makama Misau
    September 24, 2012

    I finally found the distinction, relationship and dichotomy between politics and administration. Thanks to Goodnow

  8. ena awo
    July 6, 2014

    Fnks alot for this important info. Really benefited. Bt I also want to kno if Frank Goodnow set the tone for the scientific study of public administration as a distant field.


Leave a Reply


7 + four =